I think there are three ways to look at this film.
The first is that it is a masterpiece. Certainly that’s what the majority of critics and other creatives think about it. the New York Times ranked it number two on their list of 100 best movies of this century.
That’s one of the reasons why I watched it. Or watched it again. There is a possibility that I watched a DVD of this 20 some years ago and simply forgot everything about it.
The second interpretation is that this is an emperor has no clothes moment. Where all of the critics and movie makers are wrong and this is a bad movie that the culture has decided is good simply to go along. We as a society are never so smart that we are more than 5 seconds away from Tulip Mania.
The culture loves something until we all decide it was bad and we never loved it at all. We have always been at war with Eastasia! Mulholland Drive is a masterpiece!
There is almost no performer, writer or director who doesn’t get dragged down eventually. It’s just that a precious few are able to rise back up.
So this could be a bad movie and everyone else is wrong.
The third option is that I am a stupid person. And you, out there reading this, you who also did not like the flick, you too could be unintelligent. Never discount the possibility that you are a dumb-dumb.
There is a particular comic book writer that everybody likes. No I’m not going to name him. But his thing was to take really obscure references and thrown them in his comics. And like, if I have to be familiar with a particular panel of a Batman comic from 1955 in order to understand and enjoy your 2015 Batman comic I feel like the fault for my lack of enjoyment is on you and not me.
It’s possible that I am an idiot but it is also possible that you wrote a bad Batman comic.
Here’s how I feel right now about Mulholland Drive.
I feel like there is no actual answer, no interpretation and no correct way to understand this film.
And that’s not because I’m too dumb to understand it. Though, again, that’s certainly possible. But because Lynch is having a go at us. He’s off camera laughing at us as we try to interpret his dream journal.
He’s hinting at an answer that isn’t there because it can’t be there because he doesn’t know either.
I can imagine him saying, “it’s just some scenes I thought would be weird or interesting and I filmed them and edited them somewhere close to the run time of a finished film.”
When I was done with it those French guys put it out in the world.
What does it mean? It’s sound and fury suckers. You figure out what it means.
If you believe IMDB someone gave David Lynch close to 20 million in 1999 money to make this film. And that’s certainly a triumph but it’s not an artistic triumph in my mind. It’s a triumph in the same way that DB Cooper got away with all that money when after he hijacked that airplane.
In a decade or two I’ll watch Mullholland Drive again. We’ll see how I feel then.









